Is Marketing Work Making Us Stupid?

Photo curtesy of jbhill via Flickr I would like to do something a little different on this lovely Friday. Instead of presenting an argument or commenting on a piece of news, I would like to throw out a question to you. (Yes, you!) I need your help, so dip your figurative quills in the ink well and read on.

Here's something you probably don't know about me: I have a terrible memory. That's what people tell me anyway. I forget birthdays and I was never good at remembering phone numbers (ah, the days before cell phones).

I'm the type of person who walks into a store and, when they come out, can't figure out which direction they came from. (Malls were especially difficult as I recall.) It's not because I'm stupid - it's because I'm analyzing the advertisement they posted in the window, the customer service of the employees, and whether the discount rate of the sale was more or less than was offered online.

And then I noticed a passage in Malcolm Gladwell's book, Blink (page 186 for those of you following along at home). Gladwell describes giving a group of his Manhattan friends the Pepsi challenge - figure out which drink is Coke and which is Pepsi while blindfolded. And yet none of his urban friends, pinkies presumably high in the air, could tell the difference. "They may drink a lot of cola, but they don't ever really think about colas."

But marketers must think deeply about these experiences. In whatever field you work, do you have an extraordinary sensitivity? Do you have a Spidey-sense about messaging?

And this leads back to my original problem with memory. I'm working on the theory that marketers focus so much on both the big-picture issues (think branding) and small details (think bounce rate) that they may lose some of the information in the middle. Is this the case for you? Or is this just a bunch of baloney?

Maybe there's nothing to this theory, but I have met quite a few marketers who fit these qualifications. These are folks who can wax poetic at dinner about complicated communication theories and the most intricate of web metrics...but need a pen and paper to figure out how much tip to leave after the bill comes.

Are marketers missing out on the middle? Heck, is working in marketing making up stupid?

After all, we aren't much use to our family if we think big and small, but not so good in-between. Most of life happens in the in-between part. I would love to hear your opinions in the comments section below. Is this theory bold or bunk?

If you enjoyed this post, then please stumble it, sphinn it, or choose an option below.